Nail It or Fail It

Nail It Or Fail It is the Second round on Nailed It! and Nailed It! Holiday!

In the second challenge, "Nail It or Fail It", contestants have two hours to recreate a complicated cake from scratch. They each receive a "Panic Button", which allows them to get three minutes of assistance from one of the judges. The worst-performing baker from the first challenge gets a second button to distract the other bakers – the specific function varies depending on the episode, but normally involves Nicole annoying the bakers. The three judges decide on the winning cake based upon presentation and taste. The winner receives a trophy and the $10,000 prize.

Trivia

 * In one episode, celebrity contestant Paul Scheer decided to split the $10,000 between his competitors and keep the trophy.